Just when you think, it cannot get any more bizarre

Okay, I am mystified here; in fact, I just want to scream, “Are you really that stupid?” Apparently, the two agents instrumental in the investigation of Ross Ulbricht and the original Silk Road Tor market place were. From Wired magazine today, “DEA special agent Carl Force and Secret Service special agent Shaun Bridges were arrested Monday and charged with wire fraud and money laundering. “ If you have not already read the Affidavit of Special Agent Tigran Gambaryan  in Support of the Criminal Complaint filed in the Northern District of California against them, I encourage you to do so. If for nothing else, you will get a good laugh.

We have talked about supporting the federal agencies involved in this case and waiting until the facts are in before determining guilt. Well, the facts are in, the charts laid out and the Bitcoins spent. These two idiots, who held themselves out as experts in online investigations, certainly had no idea how to be successful criminals.  Both of them need to go back to school on that topic. In reading the affidavit, it is clear that the two of them thought they were smarter than their counterparts. Special Agent Gambaryan does a masterful job laying out his investigation into former agents Force and Bridges trip through stupidcriminalville. Force and Bridges, like the person they arrested for Silk Road, failed to use some of the basic online security procedures. Neither apparently had worked any major international fraud cases (if they had they didn’t use anything they learned) because they had no idea how to hide and move large amounts of money without using their own names and bank accounts.

Okay, back to the basics here…If you are an undercover officer, don’t commit crimes while undercover. Oops, they must have been absent that day in the basic undercover agent course.

Advertisements

United States Attorney’s Office – 1/Ross Ulbricht – 0

Ross Ulbricht, 30, was found guilty by a Manhattan federal jury on all seven counts in the indictment he was charged.  He was convicted as the mastermind behind the original version of the Tor Hidden Service known as the Silk Road. The pundits have already begun to take apart the prosecution’s case saying it was unfair. The maligning of Judge Forrest’s handling of the case before and during the trial has begun in earnest. Even Ulbricht’s attorney, Joshua Dratel, is being questioned publically for his apparent lack of a real defense.  Some explaining he simply set the stage for the inevitable appeal.

silk_road01 Guilty

So what happens next?  Well Ross still has a pending indictment for the murder-for-hire plot in the Maryland District. Whether or not he will go to trial on that charge is unknown at this time. But, a betting man might consider that will be a slam dunk too based on the evidence presented in New York.

So how was Ross convicted when he wasn’t guilty according to his defense? What I have said before is exactly what the U.S. Attorney’s office presented; they put on a typical drug trial. Ross Ulbricht was convicted because of the drug case not because of his inventive method of using Tor as a “Social Experiment”. The Tor Hidden Service was only the vehicle by which the drug conspiracy was conducted. The Assistant United States Attorney (AUSA) Serrin Turner put the pieces together one by one and connected the face of Ross Ulbricht to the online persona Dread Pirate Roberts (DPR). They moved the evidence collected from the real world through the medium of communication, which just happened to be Tor. The AUSA used cooperating witnesses to explain the drug trade and like in any good drug trial followed the money straight back to Ross Ulbricht. Never mind that the money was in what the jury probably thought was some obscure online money trading system. Money for drugs is just that, money for drugs.  Ross Ulbricht is now, not just a famous drug King pin, but a convicted one.

Silk Road 2.0: A Cheap Imitation of the Original

Last week it was announced that law enforcement had again taken down illegal Tor markets. Kudos to law enforcement on their apparent success! Although, they took down several such online market places, the one that caught everyone’s attention was Silk Road 2.0, the heir apparent to the original, shut down a little over a year ago. But has anyone really compared the original Silk Road to 2.0? It appears that 2.0 is a cheap knock off or imitation.

The Original

The first Silk Road was in operation from approximately February 2011 to October 2013, roughly 32 months. It reportedly had total sales of about $1.2 billion, earning $80 million in commissions. It also had over 13,000 in drug listings. When it was initially shut down, 26,000 Bitcoins (BTC) were seized from Silk Road accounts, worth approximately $3.6 million at the time. However, there was also 144,000 BTC, or about $28 million, seized from the purported mastermind. We have little information that it was every hacked, at least to any great extent. We have no information to date its fall was due to an undercover agent working on the inside.

Silk Road 2.0

Silk Road 2.0, operated from about November 2013 to October 2014, roughly about 12 months. One particular month’s sales were noted at $8 million. At a 5% commission, this earned the illegal business about $400,000. However, we can’t say they averaged $8 million a month. In fact, shortly after Silk Road 2.0 start-up it was hacked, losing about $1.5 million in BTC. It reportedly had drug listings of about 14,024. We have information that only about $1 million has been seized at the present time. Finally, the complaint reflects that early on an undercover agent was on board, working with the supposedly more “secure” management team.

Looking at longevity, total sales, and amount seized Silk Road 2.0 pales in comparison to the original. The only area Silk Road 2.0 appears to exceeded the original in was total drug listings. However, more listings did not translate into more money. To be fair to Silk Road 2.0, they clearly had more competition than the original. But I think that success is all negated when one considers they were hacked and had an undercover agent working on the inside.

Now we have news that Silk Road 3.0 has started up. Maybe someone should point out to the new Dread Pirate Roberts that this franchise appears to be a dead end. You can’t spend all those earned BTC commissions very well in prison, particularly if they end up being seized. One thing I would point out though, which kind of sends chills up my spine. Both Silk Road and 2.0, were not run by career drug dealers. They were run by tech savvy individuals, with no brick and mortar drug dealing expertise. With the kind of money being made it will not be long, if it hasn’t happened already, that a traditional drug dealer or gang will decide to go “high tech” into Tor’s marketplace. When that happens, this so called “safe” online market place will become a lot more dangerous for those involved. On that thought, I left a cigar lit somewhere.

Additional Reading

More Than 400 .Onion Addresses, Including Dozens of ‘Dark Market’ Sites, Targeted as Part of Global Enforcement Action on Tor Network

Operator of Silk Road 2.0 Website Charged in Manhattan Federal Court

Original Silk Road Complaint

Silk 2.0 Complaint

Silk Road 3.0 Opens for Business

The FBI’s Plan For The Millions Worth Of Bitcoins Seized From Silk Road